Best Property Managers in
Ohio

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Ohio to find the absolute elite Property Managers destinations.

Average Authority Score
61.6
across all ranked locations
Top-Rated City
Columbus
highest avg. score in Ohio
Verified Locations
98
businesses confirmed active
Cities Ranked
5
Columbus · Cleveland · Cincinnati · Toledo · Akron

Ohio Hall of Fame

B2B Realty Property Management
State Elite
1
B2B Realty Property Management
90.78
Authority
4320 Ridge Rd, Brooklyn, OH 44144

B2B Realty Property Management, located at 4320 Ridge Rd in Brooklyn, OH 44144, serves the Akron area. Residents have noted the property managers' direct engagement with tenant concerns. Ivan, a manager, has been identified as addressing repairs in a timely manner, a contrast to previous experiences with landlords.

Mason Ryan, a property manager with B2B Realty, has been recognized for facilitating smoother transitions for residents. His proactive communication between families and the company has been a point of appreciation, influencing resident decisions regarding contract renewals. Henry, another property manager, is noted for his professionalism and responsiveness to tenant inquiries.

Miles Spencer, a property manager within the organization, is described as consistently addressing questions and concerns with a focus on property maintenance and resident comfort. His dedication has been a recurring theme in tenant feedback.

OzRealty
State Elite
2
OzRealty
90.51
Authority
5429 N Detroit Ave, Toledo, OH 43612

OzRealty handles property management from their Toledo office at 5429 N Detroit Ave. During a property restoration project, Rebecca oversaw the approval of masonry work on front steps and the installation of screen doors on enclosed porches. These porches and their railings were recently repainted, contributing to the property's improved appearance. Rebecca and Larne have responded to requests.

The company also manages property transitions. Laarne assisted a new resident with their move-in process, addressing numerous questions in a timely manner. Another resident noted Bekah's thoroughness throughout the property turn process. This included identifying and addressing foundation issues while staying within an approved budget for lead requirements and property improvements, with work commencing promptly after estimate approval.

Feedback exists regarding unexpected costs and communication style. One owner reported discovering additional work needed after initial extensive repairs, followed by further "new discoveries" that increased expenses. This owner also noted a preference for text-based communication via an app over requested phone calls.

RL Property Management
State Elite
3
RL Property Management
89.89
Authority
750 Cross Pointe Rd Suite B, Columbus, OH 43230

RL Property Management, located at 750 Cross Pointe Rd Suite B, Columbus, OH 43230, has provided services to homeowners. One inspector, Drea, identified a lack of smoke detectors in three bedrooms and scheduled an appointment to ensure their installation. Another client noted that an inspector explained the inspection process clearly and assisted with resolving an issue concerning a garbage disposal.

Interaction with the application process presented initial challenges. A prospective tenant experienced delays in receiving assistance with an online application, despite repeated attempts to contact the company via multiple channels. This led to a concern about responsiveness.

The company's property management services have been positively reviewed by clients who have worked with specific managers. Lauren Begley was described as professional, efficient, and courteous. Michael Short also received commendation for his work managing multiple properties.

Cleveland Property Management Group
State Elite
4
Cleveland Property Management Group
89.00
Authority
360 Alpha Park, Highland Heights, OH 44143

Cleveland Property Management Group manages residential properties from their Highland Heights location. The company has received feedback regarding appointment cancellations without direct contact, with automated rescheduling offering options several days out. Reports indicate some properties managed by the group have shown neglect, including uncut grass and weed growth, leading to concerns about maintenance and pest control.

However, the company's responsiveness and communication have been highlighted by out-of-state landlords seeking property management. Staff interactions are described as friendly and attentive to landlord needs, with efforts made to assist in understanding their property management portal. Long-term renters have noted fair rent practices and a deposit process, alongside consistently quick and clear communication that felt valued.

Within the organization, Chastity Scott is specifically recognized for her detailed attention, clear communication, and follow-through on property matters. Her approach is characterized by anticipating needs and resolving challenges with efficiency and integrity, particularly during a family's critical medical situation. Scott's role is described as providing a calm and clear presence, offering support beyond standard property management duties.

Grand Welcome Cincinnati & Northern KY Short Term Rental Management
State Elite
5
Grand Welcome Cincinnati & Northern KY Short Term Rental Management
88.44
Authority
6020 Harrison Ave Ste 1A, Cincinnati, OH 45248

Grand Welcome Cincinnati & Northern KY Short Term Rental Management oversees properties suitable for extended family gatherings. One residence accommodated ten guests, providing ample space for communal meals and individual relaxation. Its proximity to attractions like the Ark Encounter and Creation Museum facilitated simplified travel itineraries.

The management company's offerings extend to smaller groups. A property described as "precious" proved ideal for a family of five, situated in a quiet, attractive neighborhood with a downtown area nearby. The property featured amenities for family entertainment, including games in a detached garage and downstairs area, alongside consistent water pressure and unlimited hot water.

For those visiting for medical appointments, Grand Welcome has managed properties that offer significant convenience. One listing was a five-minute drive from Cincinnati Children’s Hospital, streamlining access for families with appointments. The homes provided a comfortable and functional environment, equipped with necessary household items, fostering a sense of being at home during an important visit.

City Directory

Switch to Real Estate Agents in Ohio

We also track and rank the top real estate agents providers across Ohio.

View Ohio Real Estate Agents