Best Property Managers in
Utah

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Utah to find the absolute elite Property Managers destinations.

Average Authority Score
69.3
across all ranked locations
Top-Rated City
West Jordan
highest avg. score in Utah
Verified Locations
26
businesses confirmed active
Cities Ranked
2
West Jordan · St. George

Utah Hall of Fame

Nestwell Property Management
State Elite
1
Nestwell Property Management
98.00
Authority
8813 S Redwood Rd Ste D1, West Jordan, UT 84088

Nestwell Property Management has presented a bifurcated service history. For tenants, experiences range from initial application hurdles, including unexpected fees and canceled viewings, to a significantly improved process once a suitable property was secured. Max, a representative, is noted for his warmth, professionalism, and thorough guidance through the move-in stages. However, other tenant accounts detail persistent communication failures, such as unreturned calls and generic email responses, alongside significant delays in addressing maintenance requests like cracked windows and broken appliance parts. Inaccurate billing and threats of eviction for unacknowledged emails have also been reported.

For property owners, concerns focus on vendor oversight and financial accountability. Instances have arisen where billed maintenance work was found incomplete, and proposed repairs, such as for a washing machine, were questioned for their necessity and cost. HOA payment failures and the submission of owner statements with unverified charges, including for services not rendered or handled by the HOA, have led to significant dissatisfaction. The perception is that customer service is handled by an offshore team, diverging from the local company facade.

The core of tenant and owner complaints centers on inconsistent performance and transparency. While some individuals have reported positive interactions and efficient processes, a significant pattern emerges of slow response times to essential issues, coupled with immediate attention to charges and fees. Delays in resolving duplicate payments and legitimate safety concerns like wasp nests highlight a systemic issue with responsiveness. Furthermore, instances of ledger inaccuracies and questionable post-lease charges raise concerns about the overall reliability of financial reporting and contract adherence.

Red Rock Property Management
State Elite
2
Red Rock Property Management
94.00
Authority
301 N 200 E #1-a, St. George, UT 84770

Red Rock Property Management handles residential rentals in St. George, Utah. Keith, a member of their team, conducted a property walkthrough, addressing tenant questions and concerns. The company also coordinates responses to maintenance emergencies, such as a leaking water heater. Dylan addressed the initial report of a leaking water heater, and Sherrie managed the ongoing repair process.

The company's handling of tenant issues has drawn varied feedback. In one instance, repeated delays and damage issues for a unit led to significant disruption for prospective renters, requiring multiple lease revisions and difficult conversations regarding property storage. While a representative named Jenny was noted for accountability, another, Sherrie, was described as dismissive and interruptive. The owner eventually intervened to reach a satisfactory resolution.

Red Rock Property Management also manages owner rentals, taking responsibility for property repairs and ensuring units are ready for new tenants. They have been reported to address AC repair needs promptly. The leasing process has been characterized as straightforward, with friendly staff interactions.

Utah Property Solutions
State Elite
3
Utah Property Solutions
90.07
Authority
1226 South Jordan Pkwy Ste D, South Jordan, UT 84095

Utah Property Solutions manages properties at 1226 South Jordan Pkwy Ste D, South Jordan, UT 84095. The company handles tenant application processes, which have been noted as quick and straightforward. Issues with online portals, such as pet screening for ESA verification, were resolved promptly without delaying approvals.

The leasing process has been described as smooth, with team members like Karla, Jessie, and Ivette providing timely responses and clear communication. Updates are provided throughout the process, contributing to a less stressful move for those acquiring properties managed by this company.

For individuals relocating from out of state, Utah Property Solutions has facilitated an easier transition. Their approach is characterized by transparency and consistent information sharing. The team's responsiveness to inquiries allows clients to proceed with confidence.

Keyrenter Property Management St George
State Elite
4
Keyrenter Property Management St George
84.09
Authority
1173 S 250 W Ste 202, St. George, UT 84770

Keyrenter Property Management St. George operates from 1173 S 250 W Ste 202 in St. George, UT. This firm engages in property management services.

Adam at Keyrenter St. George worked diligently to rent out properties. He provided clear communication throughout the process. Suggestions were offered to heighten property interest, assisting individuals new to landlording.

The Keyrenter St. George team includes individuals like AJ, whose professionalism and responsiveness are noted. This group provides clarity and follow-through on property management tasks. They offer support to both property owners and tenants.

Home Key Property Management: St George, Utah
State Elite
5
Home Key Property Management: St George, Utah
83.03
Authority
162 N 400 E Bldg C #102A, St. George, UT 84770

Home Key Property Management addresses tenant needs with notable responsiveness. When a water heater failed, Kyle handled the situation promptly, coordinating plumbers and confirming satisfactory work. Another instance involved a tenant facing a property emergency; Kyle and Matt addressed the issue with urgency, replacing equipment by the following morning. Their approach prioritizes timely problem resolution.

The team at Home Key Property Management facilitates smooth transitions for property owners. For those transitioning their rental home into management, the process has been described as seamless, with the company noted for thoroughness and a helpful demeanor from the outset. Communication with staff members like Anne and Chesley has been highlighted as a positive aspect, aiding tenants in finding suitable properties.

Staff interaction stands out in tenant experiences. Ann has been noted for her welcoming presence, and Matt has stepped in to personally assist prospective renters when immediate viewings were not scheduled. Chesley is also mentioned for his assistance in matching individuals with appropriate residences. The team's ability to adapt scheduling around tenant availability simplifies the rental process.

City Directory

Switch to Real Estate Agents in Utah

We also track and rank the top real estate agents providers across Utah.

View Utah Real Estate Agents