Best Property Managers
in Madison

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Madison.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated October 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Real Property Management Greater Madison Metro
6441 Enterprise Ln Suite 115, Madison, WI 53719
Madison Properties
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.7
88.13
2 Top Level Property Management LLC
2987 Yarmouth Greenway Dr Ste 201, Fitchburg, WI 5...
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.6
83.29
3 Wisconsin Property Managers
12 S Pontiac Dr, Janesville, WI 53545
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.7
82.93
4 Superior Property Group
1220 Femrite Dr Ste 202, Monona, WI 53716
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.2
77.63
5 Prime Urban Properties
1952 Atwood Ave, Madison, WI 53704
Trusted Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.6
71.86

Expert Reviews

Real Property Management Greater Madison Metro
Madison Properties
1
Real Property Management Greater Madison Metro
88.13
Authority
6441 Enterprise Ln Suite 115, Madison, WI 53719

Real Property Management Greater Madison Metro offers property management services from its Madison, Wisconsin office. The company's team includes individuals like Melissa, noted for her ability to ease client anxieties regarding property rentals through clear explanations and a professional demeanor. Melissa's approach made a complex process feel manageable.

Chad, another representative, has been consistently noted for his positive interactions during home showings. He answers questions thoroughly and without haste, creating a comfortable environment for potential renters. His explanations of property features include detailed examples of potential usage, aiding in visualization. Chad's straightforward and informative style was appreciated by clients, even when a rental was not secured.

The team at Real Property Management Greater Madison Metro appears to prioritize clear communication and a supportive client experience. Their individual interactions suggest a commitment to addressing client concerns and facilitating understanding of the rental process.

Top Level Property Management LLC
Property Management
2
Top Level Property Management LLC
83.29
Authority
2987 Yarmouth Greenway Dr Ste 201, Fitchburg, WI 53711

Top Level Property Management LLC, located at 2987 Yarmouth Greenway Dr Ste 201 in Fitchburg, WI, handles property management for owners and tenants. The company provides services including tenant screening, rent collection, and property maintenance. They serve areas such as Madison, Sun Prairie, Middleton, Fitchburg, and Verona.

One client reported a significant issue with tenant screening, leading to costly damages to the property. The client also noted that when problems arose, they received emails requesting guidance on how to proceed, rather than proactive management. Communication with the company was described as difficult, with a lack of response to emails and requests.

Another individual's experience involved difficulty reaching the company for urgent maintenance issues. This client experienced a roof leak and found that maintenance tickets went unaddressed via the portal. Attempts to contact the company through phone and email also proved unsuccessful, with full voicemail boxes and undeliverable emails.

Wisconsin Property Managers
Property Management
3
Wisconsin Property Managers
82.93
Authority
12 S Pontiac Dr, Janesville, WI 53545

Wisconsin Property Managers, located at 12 S Pontiac Dr, Janesville, WI 53545, handles property management services in Madison. The team includes individuals like Nicole, who addresses resident inquiries with promptness and a positive demeanor. Maintenance requests are managed by personnel such as Adam. Brian has also been noted for conducting property inspections and identifying issues.

Adam has responded to repair needs, arriving at properties to address maintenance concerns. His work has involved fixing identified problems and confirming functionality. Brian's inspections have been described as efficient and informative, with a focus on bringing resident concerns to light.

The company's operational approach involves a swift response to resident issues and questions. Efforts are made to provide solutions and address concerns.

Superior Property Group
Property Management
4
Superior Property Group
77.63
Authority
1220 Femrite Dr Ste 202, Monona, WI 53716

Superior Property Group manages properties in the Madison area. Rex, a contact at the company, has been noted for assisting owners selling their condos. Technicians, such as Jason, have been dispatched to address issues, including a dryer exhaust port problem caused by birds.

Communication and coordination are highlighted aspects of Superior Property Group's operations. The team, including individuals named Rex, Charina, Jared, and Venise, has been described as responsive to issues. Online submission processes for service requests have been noted as straightforward.

In some instances, a lack of timely response and attention to safety hazards during projects has been reported. This included exposed carpet tack strips on stairs and near doorways, with complaints not receiving a reply. The company's maintenance practices were cited as a reason for these safety concerns.

Prime Urban Properties
Trusted Management
5
Prime Urban Properties
71.86
Authority
1952 Atwood Ave, Madison, WI 53704

Prime Urban Properties manages residences in Madison, Wisconsin. The company prioritizes prompt responses to maintenance requests, with staff members like Gorge and Samuel addressing issues efficiently. These individuals are noted for their professionalism and proactive problem-solving, extending beyond immediate repairs to offer preventative measures.

Residents have reported positive interactions with maintenance personnel who are described as friendly and committed to ensuring a good living experience. The ease of submitting service requests is frequently mentioned, alongside the quick turnaround time for addressing repairs and replacements within apartments. This level of attentive service contributes to resident satisfaction.

Inquiries and tours, such as those conducted by Susan at The Philben, highlight responsive communication and a helpful approach from staff. Units within their portfolio, like those at The Philben, feature clean, modern interiors with wood floors. The properties often benefit from desirable locations, balancing quiet surroundings with convenient access to amenities like public transport and local shops.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Madison?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Madison Real Estate Agents